Let’s just start with the top. But yes they would be Catholic since plenty of Catholics before Council of Trent believed in justification by faith alone.

I’m not Catholic. I just hope for Catholic reform.

Nothing makes me think so. I just hope the Catholic Church will some day return to orthodoxy

Why would he? Because it’s what the Bible teaches. It’s an essential of the faith.

I don’t expect him to but you never know what God will do.

Oh I don’t expect it. I just hope the Catholic Church can some day return to orthodoxy.

Removed. Please do not use link shorteners.

That is a classic story and classically illustrated there.